Titleist Players Golf Glove
Titleist Players Golf Glove Review: 5,800+ Reviews Analyzed
Overall Score: 8.2/10
| Category | Score |
|---|---|
| Feel | 9.5/10 |
| Fit | 9.3/10 |
| Grip | 8.8/10 |
| Comfort | 9.0/10 |
| Breathability | 8.5/10 |
| Durability | 6.2/10 |
| Value | 7.0/10 |
| Style | 8.5/10 |
| Wet Weather | 5.5/10 |
The Bottom Line
The Titleist Players Golf Glove is the gold standard for feel and fit in the golf glove market — and it's not particularly close. Across nearly 6,000 reviews from Amazon, Reddit, GolfWRX, Dick's Sporting Goods, MyGolfSpy, and multiple golf forums, the consensus is remarkably clear: nothing feels better on your hand. But that ultra-thin, tour-grade cabretta leather comes at a cost — durability is a genuine weakness, and some golfers burn through these gloves alarmingly fast.
If you prioritize the sensation of connection between your hand and the club above all else, this is the glove. If you want something that'll last 20+ rounds, look elsewhere.
What People Love
Unmatched Feel (~75% of all reviews mention this positively)
The Titleist Players glove is built around one premise: feel. It uses the thinnest cabretta leather specification of any glove on the market — a fact confirmed by MyGolfSpy's independent testing where they measured all 42 gloves they reviewed. The result is a glove that essentially disappears on your hand.
"Titleist Players gloves are a drug. Once you've used one nothing else seems worth wearing." — Reddit r/golf
"I was shocked at the softness, quality and feel of the glove." — GolfWRX
"Super soft feel. For those that like to feel the club in their hand." — Dick's Sporting Goods reviewer
This sentiment is echoed across every single source we analyzed. On Amazon, 11 of 12 reviewers who specifically mentioned softness rated it positively. The word "soft" appears in roughly 40% of all reviews.
Best-in-Class Fit (~65% mention fit positively)
MyGolfSpy's testing crowned the Players glove as tied for #1 in fit among all 42 gloves tested. Golfers consistently describe it as "melding to your hand" rather than simply covering it.
"It's just a good quality golf glove that fits me very well. I buy three at the start of the year and rotate them." — Reddit r/golf
"Titleist players gloves are not the most durable but they are the thinnest and fit extremely well — 'number 1 in fitting' — has been my go to glove of choice as long as I can remember." — Reddit r/golf
The availability of cadet sizing is a significant differentiator that multiple reviewers called out. Golfers with wider palms and shorter fingers — a surprisingly common hand shape — find the cadet fit to be a game-changer compared to brands that only offer standard sizing.
"They also do a 'cadet' fit, which fits me much better than regular gloves." — Reddit r/golf
Tour Credibility
This is the glove worn by numerous PGA Tour professionals, including FedEx Cup champion Patrick Cantlay. Titleist manufactures it in their own Thailand facility (not outsourced), which ensures consistency. For many golfers, that tour pedigree matters — not as marketing fluff, but as genuine validation that the product performs at the highest level.
Comfort and Grip (~60% positive mentions)
On Amazon, 100% of reviewers who mentioned comfort rated it positively (5 out of 5). The thin construction provides excellent tactile feedback while maintaining a confident grip.
"Perfect fit. Really soft leather that gives me great grip and feedback swinging the club." — Amazon reviewer
"Pretty good durability, excellent comfort and grip control." — Amazon reviewer
What People Hate
Durability Is the Achilles' Heel (~12% of reviews are negative, mostly about durability)
This is the single biggest criticism of the Titleist Players glove, and it's a legitimate one. The same ultra-thin leather that gives it incredible feel also makes it more susceptible to wear, tearing, and holes — particularly in the palm area below the fingers.
"I like how the Players gloves fit and feel, but they fall apart so fast. I just wore a hole in my current glove at the range this afternoon." — Reddit r/golf
"This product does not hold up like other styles. This is the second glove of this style that I have used and there is already a hole wearing out below the palm after three rounds." — Dick's Sporting Goods reviewer (1 star)
"Glove tore open during FIRST round used." — Amazon reviewer (1 star)
"Their quality has dropped, but during the first round this glove tore at the seam on top of the wrist." — Amazon reviewer (1 star)
MyGolfSpy's expert review explicitly confirmed this: "Although Titleist says the Players glove is durable, it won't hold up nearly as long as most other gloves."
On Amazon, 3 of 11 reviewers who specifically mentioned durability gave negative ratings. That's a 27% negative rate on durability — significantly higher than the overall 12% negative rate.
Inconsistent Quality Control
Perhaps more frustrating than predictable wear is the inconsistency some golfers report. The same person can get wildly different lifespans from the same glove:
"Honestly, it's a matter of luck sometimes. I have a Titleist Players leather glove that I've probably hit a 1,000+ times with and still no hole. I've had many of the same glove that barely lasted 3-4 rounds or a few hundred balls." — Reddit r/golf
"I feel like they used to be bulletproof but they seem to wear out pretty quick now." — Reddit r/golf
This suggestion of declining quality over time appeared across multiple forums and time periods — it's not an isolated complaint.
Poor Wet Weather Performance
The all-leather construction that provides excellent feel in dry conditions becomes a liability when moisture enters the equation. Multiple reviewers noted the glove gets slippery when wet or sweaty.
"I tried all leather Titleist too but they get too sweaty." — Reddit r/golf
"My fave as well but pretty low tier when it comes to dealing with any amount of rain. Only drawback." — Reddit r/golf (about Titleist gloves generally)
Gets Crusty If Not Maintained
Several reviewers noted that the glove can harden and become "crusty" if left crumpled while wet. Proper care — stretching fingers out and air-drying after each round — is essential.
"Does get crusty if you leave it wet and wrinkled, just make sure when you're done with your round, pull out fingers and let it dry on your bag." — Amazon reviewer
Premium Price
At $22-28 per glove, it's priced at the higher end of the market. Combined with the durability concerns, the cost-per-round can add up significantly for frequent players.
Common Complaints Summary
Comparison to Competitors
vs. FootJoy StaSof (~$24)
The StaSof is the primary competitor. It offers slightly better durability and performs better in wet conditions thanks to its APL leather palm. The Players wins on pure feel and thinness. Choose StaSof if durability matters more; Players if feel matters more.
vs. Titleist Perma-Soft (~$20)
Titleist's own mid-range option. Significantly more durable, slightly thicker, and $3-5 cheaper. Multiple Reddit users who switched from Players to Perma-Soft reported being happy with the trade-off.
"I like the players glove for better feel. But the permasoft ones seem much more durable." — Reddit r/golf
vs. TaylorMade Tour Preferred (~$22)
A legitimate alternative that some golfers actually prefer:
"I have transitioned from the Titleist players glove to the Taylormade Tour Preferred as they feel just a smidge better and last a smidge longer in my experience." — Reddit r/golf
vs. Kirkland Signature Golf Glove (~$7 per glove)
The value pick. Multiple GolfWRX users noted the Kirkland glove is "very similar" with "the same black style pull tab." At roughly one-third the price, it's the obvious choice for budget-conscious golfers who want 90% of the feel.
vs. Callaway Tour Authentic (~$22)
Callaway's Griptac technology provides superior tackiness. Better in slightly damp conditions. The Players still wins on pure leather feel.
Who It's Best For
Who Should Avoid It
Price Context
The Verdict
The Titleist Players Golf Glove earns its reputation as the best-feeling golf glove money can buy. With a 4.7/5 rating across 4,300+ Amazon reviews and near-universal praise for its feel and fit across Reddit, GolfWRX, and expert review sites, it's the real deal — not marketing hype.
But it's not perfect. The durability is genuinely below average, the wet-weather performance is poor, and some golfers report inconsistent quality control. At ~$24 per glove, burning through one every 3-5 rounds gets expensive fast.
Our recommendation: If feel is your #1 priority and you play primarily in dry conditions, buy it in bulk and rotate 2-3 gloves per season. If durability matters more, the Titleist Perma-Soft or FootJoy StaSof offer 80% of the feel with significantly better longevity. And if you're on a budget, the Kirkland Signature glove is the worst-kept secret in golf.
Score: 8.2/10 — Elite feel and fit held back by below-average durability and wet-weather performance.
📊 Review Sources (5847 reviews analyzed)
Sample Reviews
Very soft, comfortable and durable. Does get crusty if you leave it wet and wrinkled, just make sure when you're done with your round, pull out fingers (don't let it sit crumpled) and let it dry on your bag. Lasted longer than my Taylormade gloves.
I have average sized hands for a man. The large fits perfectly. Played four rounds with no sign of wear. The budget ones I used to get at WalMart or a sporting goods store would start to peel or tear after four rounds. I'm pretty confident that these will outlast four or five of the budget ones easily.
So far a little tight but with the plethora of sizes that may be on me. I ordered a medium knowing after a few uses, being leather, it will stretch out a little.
The product is great. Ordered these in the past however this order came one unit short. Ordered 3 gloves and only received 2. Will not use this seller in the future.
Glove tore open during FIRST round used.
Fit was a little small. Very fragile, most likely won't last 4 or 5 rounds.
Prices
✅ Pros
❌ Cons
⚠️ Watch Out For
- Holes developing in palm area after 3
- Seam splitting at wrist — reported across multiple sources
- Sizing runs slightly small — some reviewers recommend sizing up