FootJoy · Golf Gloves
FootJoy WeatherSof Golf Glove
9,782 reviews analyzed
Source: golfgalaxy.com
FootJoy WeatherSof Golf Glove Review: The World's Best-Selling Glove Analyzed (9,700+ Reviews)
Overall Score: 8.4/10 | Amazon ASIN: B0767RRCDR (Prior Gen single), B00OKZF4IO (single), B0160XFSYI (2-pack) | Price: ~$12-14 single, ~$20-23 for 2-pack | Rating: 4.6/5 on Amazon (9,581 ratings)
The Bottom Line
The FootJoy WeatherSof is the world's #1 selling golf glove for a reason: it delivers exceptional durability and reliable grip at a price point that makes premium leather gloves look like a bad investment. With over 90 million gloves sold and a 4.6/5 rating across nearly 10,000 Amazon reviews, this synthetic/leather hybrid has earned its place in the bags of 1 in 5 American golfers. It won't give you the buttery-soft, tour-pro feel of a $25+ cabretta leather glove, but for the vast majority of recreational golfers, the WeatherSof is the smartest money you'll spend on a golf accessory.
Score Breakdown
| Category | Score | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Overall | 8.4/10 | Best-in-class value proposition |
| Durability | 9.0/10 | Outlasts leather gloves 2:1 |
| Value for Money | 9.5/10 | ~$12 single, lasts 20-40 rounds |
| Fit | 8.5/10 | Wide size range incl. cadet; consistent |
| Grip | 8.2/10 | Leather palm patches deliver |
| Comfort | 8.0/10 | PowerNet mesh helps; ComforTab closure |
| Breathability | 7.5/10 | Decent for synthetic; mesh helps |
| Feel/Touch | 7.0/10 | Noticeably less tactile than leather |
What 9,700+ Golfers Actually Say
What People Love (~85% Positive Sentiment)
1. Durability Is King (Mentioned in ~60% of positive reviews)
The single most praised attribute of the WeatherSof is how long it lasts. Across Amazon, Reddit, and golf forums, durability comes up more than any other factor.
"Honestly FootJoy's WeatherSof gloves last so much longer than any other glove on the market that I think it's a loss not to buy them." — Reddit r/golf
"A WeatherSof glove may last up to twice as many rounds as a high-end leather glove." — Golfalot
"FootJoy WeatherSof gloves are like $12 and seem to last forever." — Reddit r/golf
The Golfalot reviewer documented his glove after 5 full 18-hole rounds with "minor discoloration, but absolutely no signs of wear or tear." Multiple Reddit users report getting 20-40 rounds out of a single glove, which is remarkable compared to premium leather gloves that often show significant wear after 5-10 rounds.
2. Unbeatable Value (~45% mention price/value)
At roughly $12 for a single glove or $23 for a 2-pack, the WeatherSof offers arguably the best cost-per-round of any name-brand golf glove. This comes up constantly in Reddit "best value" threads.
"FootJoy WeatherSof - 2 pack for around $20. Best value out there." — Reddit r/golf
"I can buy a Footjoy or Callaway glove and it will last longer than an entire 4-pack of Kirklands." — Reddit r/golf
The value comparison to Kirkland Signature gloves (the Costco darling) is particularly telling. While Kirkland gloves are cheaper per unit (~$7-8 each in a 4-pack), multiple users report the WeatherSof lasts so much longer that the cost-per-round actually favors FootJoy.
3. Handles Moisture and Sweat Well (~25% mention)
The "Weather" in WeatherSof isn't just marketing. The FiberSof synthetic material and PowerNet mesh inserts handle humidity, sweat, and light rain far better than all-leather alternatives.
"Footjoy WeatherSof. Most durable, most comfortable, best in wet conditions or sweaty hands, and not very expensive." — Reddit r/golf
"Where all-leather gloves need to be aired out after they get wet and often take a while to recover, the WeatherSof can absorb a little rain and sweat better." — Golfalot
4. Reliable Fit and Comfort (~30% mention)
The ComforTab velcro closure and PowerNet mesh knuckle inserts create a glove that fits consistently and comfortably. The wide size range (S-XXL plus cadet sizes) means most golfers can find their fit.
"I've been testing different glove brands and footjoy by far has a better fit and feel. The fingers are the correct length so there's no extra hanging over." — Golf Galaxy reviewer
"When you slide your hand into the WeatherSof it certainly doesn't feel like you're shopping at the lower end of the market." — Golf Monthly
What People Hate (~10% Negative Sentiment)
1. Not as Luxurious as Leather (~40% of negative mentions)
The most common criticism is that the WeatherSof simply doesn't feel as premium as full-leather gloves like the FootJoy StaSof or Titleist Players. This is fair — it's a synthetic glove at half the price.
"Doesn't feel as luxurious or offer as great touch in the fingers as more premium, all-leather gloves." — Golf Monthly
"Much better quality than the Weathersoft [StaSof is better]... they make a cheaper Contour glove that has a similar soft leather feel." — Reddit r/golf
2. Quality Control Concerns (~15% of negative mentions)
A recurring theme across forums is that quality may have declined over the years, or varies between production batches. Some long-time buyers have noticed changes.
"I have used a FJ golf glove for over 25 years and this product is nothing like it used to be. After one round the glove starts to breakdown almost becoming slimy on the inside." — Amazon reviewer
"Previously the glove would last for ages, but with this new one the top layer has started coming off around the fingers after only a few rounds. The new one was made in Taiwan vs. Vietnam." — Golf Monthly Forum
"I wonder if Footjoy has found a cheaper (and inferior) factory to get them made." — Golf Monthly Forum
3. Sizing Inconsistencies (~20% of negative mentions)
Some buyers report that sizing runs small or varies between production runs.
"I'm typically a XL size in golf gloves. These fit more like a large. Very tight for my liking." — Amazon reviewer
"Gloves do not fit like Footjoy gloves and the product quality is terrible." — Amazon reviewer (suspected third-party seller issue)
4. Missing Ball Marker (~5% of negative mentions)
FootJoy removed the snap-on ball marker from newer versions, which frustrated long-time users who relied on it.
"Footjoy stopped making gloves that had a snap-on ball marker on the cuff." — Amazon reviewer
The Neutral Take (~5%)
About 5% of reviews are neutral — typically from golfers who acknowledge the WeatherSof is solid but prefer leather gloves for the feel, or who find it adequate but unremarkable. The consensus is clear: it's not the best glove you can buy, but it's almost certainly the smartest glove you can buy.
How It Compares to Competitors
vs. Kirkland Signature Golf Gloves (~$7-8 each in 4-pack)
The Kirkland comparison comes up in nearly every glove discussion thread. The verdict from the community is nuanced: Kirkland is cheaper per glove, but the WeatherSof lasts significantly longer. For golfers who sweat heavily, Kirkland gloves "crinkle and become super stiff" after a few rounds, while the WeatherSof handles moisture better. Winner for most golfers: WeatherSof (better longevity, better in moisture).
vs. FootJoy StaSof (~$22-25 single)
The StaSof is FootJoy's premium cabretta leather glove. It offers noticeably better feel and touch but at double the price and with significantly less durability. The StaSof stretches and wears out faster. Winner for feel: StaSof. Winner for value: WeatherSof by a mile.
vs. Callaway Weatherspan (~$12-14 single)
The closest direct competitor. Very similar price point and synthetic/leather hybrid construction. Community opinion is split, but WeatherSof has more mindshare and a longer track record. Essentially a toss-up, but the WeatherSof has brand loyalty on its side.
vs. Titleist Players (~$18-22 single)
The Titleist Players glove offers superior feel with its cabretta leather construction but costs more and doesn't last as long. For golfers who prioritize touch around the greens, the Titleist is better. For everyone else: WeatherSof wins on value.
Who Should Buy It
Who Should Avoid It
Price Context
| Retailer | Single Glove | 2-Pack |
|---|---|---|
| FootJoy.com | ~$14 | ~$24 |
| Amazon | ~$12-15 | ~$20-24 |
| Dick's / Golf Galaxy | ~$14 | ~$22 |
| PGA Tour Superstore | ~$14 | ~$22 |
| Carl's Golfland | — | $22.95 |
The 2-pack is almost always the better deal, saving $3-6 compared to buying two singles. Amazon occasionally runs the 2-pack below $20, which is an exceptional value.
Key Product Details
The Verdict
The FootJoy WeatherSof earns its position as the world's #1 selling golf glove. It's not the softest, not the most premium-feeling, and not going to impress anyone in the locker room. But it's incredibly durable, handles all weather conditions, fits well, grips well, and costs half what premium leather gloves cost while lasting twice as long.
The math is simple: at $12 per glove lasting 20-30 rounds, you're paying about $0.50 per round for reliable grip. A $25 leather glove lasting 10 rounds costs $2.50 per round. Unless you're a scratch golfer who can genuinely feel the difference in your short game, the WeatherSof is the rational choice.
Score: 8.4/10 — The ultimate "buy it and don't think about it" golf glove. Not flashy, not premium, just relentlessly good value.