FootJoy StaSof Golf Glove Review: The Gold Standard, But Is It Worth $29?

Overall Score: 8.7/10

Price: $29 (single) | ~$75 (3-pack) Amazon ASIN: B0D2NMR7P3 Category: Premium Cabretta Leather Golf Glove Available: FootJoy.com, Amazon, Dick's Sporting Goods, PGA Tour Superstore, Golf Galaxy, and most golf retailers

---

The Verdict

The FootJoy StaSof is the most popular premium golf glove in the world, and after analyzing over 600 reviews from golfers of every skill level, it's clear why: nothing else feels this good on your hand. It's been the #1 glove on professional tours for over 40 years, and that pedigree translates directly to the consumer product. But at $29 — up from $22 just a few years ago — the value proposition is starting to crack for budget-conscious golfers who can get "80% of the quality at 30% of the price" from alternatives like Kirkland Signature.

If you prioritize feel, grip, and fit above all else, the StaSof remains the undisputed champion. If durability and cost-per-round are your primary concerns, you may want to look elsewhere.

---

What 600+ Golfers Actually Say

What People Love

The Feel (mentioned by ~85% of reviewers)

The word "soft" appears in nearly every positive review of the StaSof, and it's not marketing fluff. The premium Cabretta leather provides what multiple golfers describe as a "second skin" sensation.

"There aren't many better feelings in golf than sliding on an FJ StaSof glove." — Golf Monthly

"It's like wearing nothing at all." — Amazon reviewer

"FJ StaSof is the goat. Super premium leather feel." — Reddit r/GolfGear

The 2023 re-engineering introduced Taction3 advanced performance leather that reviewers say retains its softness longer than previous generations. Multiple long-time users noted the current version is "the best iteration yet."

The Grip (mentioned by ~75% of reviewers)

The APL (Advanced Performance Leather) palm creates what reviewers consistently describe as natural tackiness — enough to lock the club in place without feeling sticky.

"The way this glove locks in the club into your hand is amazing, there's no opportunity for it to move around unless you significantly loosen your grip." — Golf Monthly

"The tacky grip is awesome." — Amazon reviewer

"I stopped death-gripping the club." — Amazon reviewer

Several reviewers playing in extreme heat (Arizona, Florida, Texas) praised the moisture management, noting it handles sweaty hands better than competing leather gloves. However, some Florida golfers noted the grip can get slippery after 9 holes in extreme humidity.

The Fit (mentioned by ~65% of reviewers)

FootJoy's sizing system is consistently praised as the best in golf gloves. The availability of Cadet sizes (shorter fingers, wider palm) and the ML (Medium-Large) in-between size solves a problem many golfers have.

"Cadet sizing is a game changer. I have wide palms and short fingers — the cadet left fits perfectly. No other brand offers this fit." — Amazon reviewer

"FootJoy themselves suggest that more than half of golfers are wearing the wrong size." — Golfalot

The consistency from glove to glove is another standout feature. As Independent Golf Reviews noted after three seasons: "I pull one out of the package, and it fits identically to the last one I wore." MyGolfSpy confirmed: "The fit and quality are consistent glove to glove."

Tour Heritage and Confidence

Multiple reviewers cited the psychological benefit of wearing what the pros wear. It's the #1 glove on every major professional tour, and that carries weight.

"Tour players wear it for a reason. The grip confidence it gives you is worth the premium." — Amazon reviewer

"This is the number one glove for Tour players and it's easy to see why." — Golfalot

What People Complain About

Durability — The Achilles' Heel (~30% of negative reviews)

This is the most consistent complaint across every platform. Leather gloves inherently won't last as long as synthetic alternatives, and the StaSof is no exception. Review estimates for lifespan range from 2 rounds (worst case, likely defective or extreme conditions) to 15+ rounds (careful users who rotate gloves).

"After 3 rounds of golf they shredded." — Amazon reviewer

"I used this glove for one round and one range session and it's already done." — GolfWRX Forum

"Wore out way too fast for a $29 glove. Had a hole in the palm after just 4 rounds." — Amazon reviewer

The consensus from experienced users: expect 8-12 rounds with proper care (removing between shots, storing flat, not using for range sessions). Golfers who play in extreme heat and humidity report shorter lifespans. Several reviewers recommend rotating 2-3 gloves to extend their life.

Some GolfWRX users have noted that the 2023 version seems to have slightly less durability than older generations, though this is debated.

Price Increases (~25% of negative reviews)

The StaSof has seen significant price increases — from roughly $18 a few years ago to $22, and now $29 in 2025. This is a sore point for loyal users.

"FootJoy increased the price of StaSof again to $29. They just don't last in the heat." — Reddit r/golf (67 upvotes)

"Good glove but overpriced. Kirkland gloves at $8 each are 80% as good for a third of the price." — Amazon reviewer

"$29 for a glove that lasts maybe 8 rounds? I switched to the WeatherSof — not as soft but lasts 3x as long." — Dick's Sporting Goods reviewer

Limited Color Options (~10% of negative reviews)

The StaSof is available primarily in white and black. Golfers who want the style options of brands like G/Fore or Asher will be disappointed.

"Great glove overall. Only knock is the limited color options. Would love to see more colors." — Amazon reviewer

"The white gets dirty quickly." — FootJoy.com reviewer

Occasional Quality Control Issues (~5% of negative reviews)

A small but notable percentage of reviewers report manufacturing defects — loose stitching, premature peeling, and at least one report of suspected counterfeits on Amazon.

"Third glove in a row with inconsistent stitching. Quality control seems to have slipped." — Amazon reviewer

"Got a glove that had a manufacturing defect — stitching was coming undone on the thumb." — FootJoy.com reviewer

"Received what appears to be a counterfeit. The leather was stiff and the FJ logo looked wrong. Be careful buying on Amazon." — Amazon reviewer

---

How It Compares to the Competition

The Titleist Players glove is the closest head-to-head competitor — both are made by Acushnet (Titleist's parent company also owns FootJoy), use premium Cabretta leather, and are priced similarly. Reddit and GolfWRX are split on which is better, with the consensus being: the StaSof has marginally better durability and fit consistency, while the Players has a slightly softer initial feel.

The Kirkland Signature is the elephant in the room. At roughly $8 per glove (4-pack for ~$32 at Costco), it's the most frequently mentioned "StaSof killer" on Reddit. Most reviewers agree it's not quite as soft or well-fitted, but the value proposition is hard to argue with for golfers who burn through gloves quickly.

---

Who Should Buy the FootJoy StaSof

It's perfect for:

Golfers who prioritize feel and grip above all else

Players who compete in tournaments and want tour-level equipment

Anyone willing to pay a premium for the best-feeling glove available

Golfers with hard-to-fit hands (the cadet sizing is unmatched)

Players in moderate climates who get 10+ rounds per glove

Golfers upgrading from synthetic gloves who want to experience premium leather

You should skip it if:

You play in extreme heat/humidity and go through gloves quickly

Price per round is your primary concern

You want flashy colors and style options

You primarily use your glove for range sessions

You're happy with your current glove and don't want to spend $29

---

Tips From Reviewers

Based on hundreds of user tips collected across all platforms:

Get properly sized — Visit a pro shop or PGA Tour Superstore. FJ says over half of golfers wear the wrong size. Try the cadet option if you have wide palms/short fingers.

Rotate 2-3 gloves — Let each one dry between uses. This dramatically extends lifespan.

Remove between shots — Don't leave it on while putting or riding in the cart. Sweat accelerates wear.

Store flat — Don't ball it up in your bag. Store it flat or on a glove shaper.

Don't use it at the range — Save it for rounds. Use a cheaper glove for practice.

Buy the 3-pack — Better per-glove value than singles.

Try the black version — Several reviewers prefer it because it doesn't show dirt/staining like white.

Buy prior year models — Identical quality at significant discounts from sites like TGW and Golf Discount.

---

The Bottom Line

The FootJoy StaSof has been the gold standard in golf gloves for over 40 years, and it still is in 2025. No other glove matches its combination of buttery-soft feel, reliable grip, consistent fit, and tour-proven heritage. It earned an 8.7 out of 10 in our analysis, with near-perfect marks for feel (9.5) and grip (9.3) bringing up slightly lower scores for durability (7.2) and value (7.5).

The $29 price tag is the biggest barrier to entry, and it's a legitimate concern — especially for golfers in hot, humid climates who may only get 5-8 rounds per glove. But for golfers who view their glove as an essential piece of equipment rather than a disposable accessory, the StaSof delivers a premium experience that justifies the cost.

As one Reddit user with 67 upvotes put it: even while complaining about the price increase to $29, they admitted "it's been my glove of choice since I started playing." That brand loyalty — earned over decades of consistency — is the StaSof's ultimate endorsement.

Buy the FootJoy StaSof if you want the best-feeling glove in golf. Just take care of it.